Music is incorruptible.
No matter how politicians and hucksters try
to co-opt music to their own, selfish ends,
music resists. It perseveres to reach us all.
Some like this bit, some prefer that, but music engages all:
Homo sap's universal language spanning our Babel-ious world.
No, not I: the UNDHR.
Today is the 76th birthday of the United Nations Declaration of Human Rights, three generations old and still forceful despite numerous, often systemic, violations. It is primarily but by no means solely the work of the greatest of our three Roosevelts, Teddy, Franklin, and Eleanor.
"Greatest?" Well, at least Eleanor's work is the longest lasting (unless one counts Teddy's FTC, Sherman Anti-Trust Act, and Robinson-Patman Acts; or Franklin's SEC even though these are observed more in violation that in compliance.) The declaration is often violated, certainly, but nonetheless, UNDHR has the widest impact of any of the other Roosevelts' legacies. It's thirty articles continue to inspire men and women and some government leaders throughout the world. She also inspires women by her example of hectoring her husband to respond to society's needs; of out-maneuvering Andrei Gromyko, The Soviet Ambassador to the UN; and of forging alliances with domestic Republicans and leaders from different cultures and political systems.
Now it is up to us the remind our present generation of leaders of the foundational importance of the UNDHR, May we assure its survival for another 76 years.
Many friends and I are astounded at the inappropriateness of nearly all of Trump's nominees. My hunch (only that) is that those who are pulling the strings on The Don Marionette are intentionally showing their disdain for and contempt of our democratic-republican governance institutions. By putting in place totally unqualified persons they strengthen their case for turning over government to a competent, capable autocrat and his cabal.
My prediction (only that) is that they will talk him off his tariff limb; into reductions of corporate and capital gains tax rates; into repeal of the surcharge tax on high incomes; into entitlement cuts; into a work-visa plan that exempts holders from wage and benefit minimums and assures a steady supply of low-wage labor; into restrictions on unionizing; into cancellation of student debt forgiveness and Pell grants; and into large DOD cost-plus contract appropriations. This group of confident, self-interested elitists will increase income and wealth inequalities, not reduce them.
No sense my writing my two resistor Senators, Cantwell and Murray. As for other states', only constituents can get through to them. So, please, if you of a mind and live in another than Washington State; write or leave a voice mail for your Senators -- especially Republican ones -- urging them to stiffen up and re-assert Senate responsibility to advise and consent only to nominees who are qualified to manage these complex institutions of government. There is too much at stake for Senators to cave-in to the (cabal-directed?) MAGA threats and intimidation -- and cave they will if their constituents do not speak up.
When you aspire to do more than energy and will can deliver,
despair not.
Regret is but a waste of time and a poison to the spirit.
Rejoice.
Rejoice in partial achievement
~~~~
and never diminish your aspirations.
A sincere, deeply concerned friend of mine asked, by e-mail, for my advice on and assistance in launching a last-minute campaign to forestall the incoming administration's abandonment of Ukraine. The idea is to advertise and use social media networks to position Ukraine as "Good" in a fundamentalist Christian way, i.e., as having voluntarily given up their nuclear arsenal in the name of Peace; as having faith in the protective guarantees of the Budapest Memoranda signed both by the Russian Federation and the United States; and as being an innocent victim of Vladmir Putin, the "Evil" in this scenario. The hope is to gin up an irresistible tide of public demand for continued support of Ukraine.
Here is how I replied:
Every time Pres. Trump calls “fight”, I wince a little. (Just as I wince at “President Trump” but that’s another story.) And every time Harris or Walz calls “fight”, I am filled with regret. We shout “fight” too readily, too eagerly, altogether too often. Teddy Roosevelt coached us to speak softly but carry a big stick. Instead, we shout “fight” at every opportunity, whether wielding a big stick or no.
I know: that sounds really preachy. But my God, wouldn’t you
agree that our society has become steeped in conflict, in violence? Teens would
rather strike out than talk; adults trash talk to the point of assault; violence
in our neighborhoods doesn’t alarm us; the daily morning papers’ reports of last
night’s homicides no longer shock us. We simply shrug , shake our heads, say OMG,
and peruse on. Fight is a worldwide affliction – in Gaza and the West Bank, in
Ukraine, in Beirut, in Abuja and Asmara, in Karachi and Maungdaw and Manipur,
and on and on.
From both Democrats and Republicans: “next time, we must fight
harder”. “when we fight, we win”, “worth fighting for”, “you won’t have a
country unless you fight for it”. . . fight, fight, fight. Our sports teams
fight. Television is full of fight: Mixed Martial Arts and the Ultimate Fighting
Championship and tonight's 58 year-old Mike Tyson's return to the ring: brutal, gladiatorial violence in full view from your
couch. You don’t have to go to the Coliseum to see the blood ooze and sometimes
spurt.
Churchill, or was it Harold Macmillan, said “jaw, jaw is
better than war, war.” And wasn’t Churchill as warlike as could be? But he knew
when to war and when to talk. Perhaps we need more willingness to war in Crimea
and Donetsk, and more willingness to talk in Taipei and Teheran. And better
yet, perhaps less jaw, jawing and more listen, listening.
If each of us were to abjure “fight”, to banish it from our
vocabulary, might we not move the needle a little? It wouldn’t hurt to try.
Born in Ohio (seven years) and raised in Maryland (ten
years), I call Minnesota and Washington home. I lived 23 years in the land of
Hiawatha and Paul Bunyon, and now have lived in Tyee country (Chinook for boss)
for 39 years. And I am proud to be an Minne-Washing-sotan.
Minnesota went for Harris: the Democratic-Farmer-Labor Party took 51% despite Republicans, Greens, Libertarians, We The Peoples, Socialist & Libertarians. Socialists, Justice for Alls parties and Independents being on the ballot.
 |
| Paul Bunyan's girlfriend, Lucette; I've paid my respects to Lucette, in Hackensack, Minnesota (walleye country!) |
And what of Washington? Washington went more blue this year than in 2020, the only state in the Union to do so. The Harris/Vance ticket took 58% (! ! !) of the vote.
 |
| The Tyee of Salmon, by Preston Singleterry Roll on Columbia! |
All I can surmise is that sons and daughters of Minnesota and Washington (and, yes, adopted sons, too) are wise, aware, thoughtful, loyal to our Republic, and prepared to defend the election processes that protect us from autocrats.
PS If you haven't yet watched Tim Walz's speech to supporters when back in Minnesota, do so. It is a classic in consoling, empathizing, motivating and energizing. Here's the link: note but do not discount the source -- it's reliable.
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/tim-walz-speaks-after-2024-election-full-speech/vi-AA1tLt08?category
(Stick that in your eye, Rupert.)
A friend asked me for whom I was voting. I told her my vote was as private as the color of her underwear – no, not really, but that’s what I later thought of having said. Upon reflection, I will tell you what I’m not voting for.
I’m not voting for a felon to become President of the United
States, an office I respect and honor, one whose occupant I was raised to
look up to. As I grew older, I came to see the occupants as humans flawed in
their ways, but still deserving respect as exemplars of public service, earning respect for
shouldering the awesome responsibility of the worst job in the world. I believe,
moreover, in the rule of law and cannot countenance a felon in that role.
I’m not voting for a person who objectifies people, as
in viewing casualties of war as “suckers”; as in labelling heroes “losers”; as in objecting
to the funeral expenses of a murdered US servicewoman, “a fucking Mexican”; as
in saying of beautiful women that “When you’re a star . . . you can do anything.
You can grab them by the pussy. You can do anything.” As in calling immigrants who have the courage to leave
home and struggle to come to America “vermin.”
I’m not voting for a person who admires flagrant autocrats
such as Vladimir Putin, Viktor Orban, Kim Jong Un, and Xi Jinping, all of whom
are openly hostile to our democratic ideals and to our role in the world.
I’m not voting for a person who views Roy Cohn as a role
model; yes, that Roy Cohn: hypocrite, amoral, manipulative, self-absorbed.
I’m not voting for a person who fails to win the respect
and allegiance of his staff, people who filled key positions of trust and
accountability and who now testify to that person’s lack of trustworthiness and
leadership capability.
I’m not voting for a person who is a serial liar, who
tells the big lie over and over, as in who won the 2020 election, and little ones
again and again, as in whose inaugural crowd was larger, his or his predecessor’s.
I’m not voting for a radical willing to throw over the systems
and institutions that have served us rather than, as true conservatives do,
work to improve them increment by increment.
. . .
And I suggest you don’t either.
. . . for whom to vote for President. Should I vote for Shiva Ayyadurai, independent, or for Claudia De la Cruz and Karina Garcia of the Socialism and Liberation Party, or for Crystal Ellis, Independent, or for Rachele Fruit and Dennis Richter of the Socialist Workers Party, or for Kamala Harris and Tim Walz of the Democratic Party, or for Robert Kennedy and Nicole Shannon of the We The People Party, or for Joseph Kishore and Jerry White of the Socialist Equality Party, or for Chase Oliver and Mike ter Maat of the Libertarian Party, or for Jill Stein and Robert Ware of the Green Party, or for Donald Trump and JD Vance of the Republican Party, or for Cornel West and Melina Abdullah of the Justice for All Party? OMG, what to do?
Perhaps Washington State has carried representative democracy one step too far: we have more candidates than electors! (Twelve.)
Crystal is a nice name for a President. And I've always liked equality; equality is good, too.
The Oncorhynchus have returned, an encore of sorts for the species, though not for the beautiful individuals who struggle to arrive and then die for the cause.
Don’t we all in our own ways, struggle to survive, to arrive, and die?
Issaquah Fish Hatchery
Last Wednesday, a beautiful Indian summer day, three friends and I visited the Issaquah Fish Hatchery where 16,000 Oncorhynchus – better known as “Chinook” here in the Pacific Northwest where Chinookan was the common language of our First Nations clustered around the Columbia, or “tshawytscha” in a Russian-tainted Lushootseed, the language of Vancouver and Puget Sound, or “black-mouth salmon”, or “Kings” or "Tyee" --
 |
| Waiting to move up. These are about 30", 25#'s. |
Walk around block milestone
Sunday morning, I had my own survival arrival: my first walk around the block since contracting pneumonia in Carcassonne in May and being hospitalized in Clinic Universidad de Navarra, in Pamplona. That trek up the gentle slope and down again around my little block was a triumph. I didn’t get to shoot sperm at eggs – those days just a distant memory – but no less satisfying. Time is all I have to invest now.
Mt Rainier (I don't put a period after it because it's still alive.)
Every couple of years we also get wonderful views of lenticular clouds forming over, formed by, actually, another icon of our region, Mt. Rainier.
 |
| Lenticular Cloud created by Mt Rainier |
Boeing, Starbucks, REI
That plant in front of Rainier and its lid is where the infamous Boeing 737 Maxes are assembled, on the shore of Lake Washington. Boeing is the fourth icon of the Puget Sound region, badly wounded by mis-management and its Board of Directors' feckless lack of accountability. (See May 27th, below.)
Boeing is not alone: Seattle icons Starbucks and REI have hit rough patches, too. But nobody has yet been killed by a latte or a merino tee.
Microsofties are still transcendent.
New aquarium and waterfront park. New glass.
Seattle is getting a new waterfront and a new aquarium addition. And for my recent birthday, I gave my self a new piece of glass by Preston Singletary, one of the Tlinglit people: his take on Oncorhynchus, no less – just to close the loop on this rambling rumination.
 |
| Salmon Chief by Preston Singletary |
All my life I have been chided to “act your age.” Born on a September 11th, I was always the youngest in my class. By the blessings of Taylor and Waller genes, I have been youthfully limber and have a relatively flat belly; while not much of an athlete, I had good reflexes and agility; and I still enjoy a Taylor, full head of hair. So, I've grown accustomed to being seen as “youthful.” But since having contracted pneumonia in May, making a very slow recovery, and having turned 90 this September, I suddenly seem to be doing it – acting my age, that is -- and it’s the shits.
The symptoms are increased wobbliness – I’m using a walking stick on occasion, which belies youthfulness and exposes the new nonagenarian. The legs get heavy and breath very short upon the least exertion. Suddenly, I am acting my age indeed. As a nurse friend of Ann's counseled her, "recognize that he has a 90-year-old heart in a 90-year-old body." Thanks. Happy Birthday.
 |
| l to r: I, Ella J., Tonya A., Amy S., Corriell S., Jeff S., Steve W., Grant J. |
 |
| Four Grandkids: Max, Ella, Molly, and Corriell. The other five were in France, Toronto, Brooklyn, Midland, and Rochester |
 |
| The Clan Rapt (?) by Fletch's Version of Sinatra's It Was a Very Good Year |
Ann organized a wonderful, family birthday celebration – eighteen of us. Ann is my strength. Ann and I are still seeking answers. What has caused this
sudden change in Fletch? What, if anything, can be done to re-build his balance
and stamina? And most important, how regain confidence that we can go, we can
be, we can do?
Do what? Go to summer school at Cambridge again next summer;
take another OAT trip, perhaps to Aquitaine or to Normandy and Brittany or
perhaps a Road Scholar outing to Germany; get back to weightlifting and walking
in the woods near our home; finishing the marble bas-relief, The Cellist;
snowshoeing once more in Sun Valley.
Oh, I’m still mentally active, reading voraciously, giving Olympic Club talks. writing and volunteering for Pratt; working on the profile and history of the Chamber Society. What I’m not doing, though, is being physically active and on the go. While it’s distressing, . . .
. . .this, too, will pass.
Had James Earl Carter not been President, we’d still be reading today that a remarkable American has become a centenarian.
This young man from tiny Plains, Georgia aspired to stretch
out into the world while staying rooted in cotton and peanut country. 1n 1942, he
appealed to Georgia Congressman Stephen Pace for appointment to The US Naval
Academy (which Ann and I visited last year with my niece and nephew and their spouses)
and was graduated with distinction in 1946. After two years on surface ships,
he applied for submarine duty, serving as electronics officer dealing with a
new SONAR array development. He rose to become engineering officer, and eventually Exec
Officer of SSK-1, the Barracuda.
Later, when nuclear sub development was
undertaken, Carter sought entry, was interviewed and selected by then-captain
Hymen Rickover, and was assigned to the Naval Reactor Branch of the Atomic
Energy Commission to assist “in the design and development of nuclear
propulsion plants for naval vessels.” (Carter joined in November of ’52; my Dad
had left the AEC that previous June.)
Carter was slated to become engineering officer on the
Seawolf, one of the first nuclear subs. But in summer of ’53, his father died,
leaving a struggling peanut farm. Lieutenant Jimmy Carter resigned to attend to
family affairs and returned to Plains. In ’46, he and Rosalynn Smith, another
Plains born and bred, had married. Now in civilian lives, Jimmy studied
agronomy and Rosalynn studied finance and accounting; he grew and harvested,
she managed the books. It was a partnership that lasted.
Jimmy and Rosalynn became stalwarts of the local Baptist
Church, where Jimmy taught Sunday School over decades, well into the 21stC.
Along the way, he
· `` Revitalized his family peanut business.
· `` Served as chair of the Sumpter County school
board.
· `` Gradually became a committed civil rights
activist and an anti-segregationist Democrat.
· `` Was elected to the Georgia Senate after successfully
challenging a fraudulent election and winning the court-ordered re-election.
· `` Ran for and became Governor of Georgia,
defeating Republican and Democratic segregationists.
· `` As Governor Carter, he re-designed state
government, consolidating over 300 separate departments into 22, created youth
development programs, education programs for the incarcerated, and equalized state support for education between rural and urban areas.
· `` Helped found, fund and promote Habitat for
Humanity.
· `` Fought for just and fair democratic elections elsewhere
and formed a process for monitoring and reporting on foreign elections,
especially in Africa and South and Central America.
· `` Wrote twenty-two books, one jointly with Rosalynn
Carter (about which both said with a laugh that they’d never make that mistake
again.)
Of course, Jimmy Carter did become our 39th President, a presidency buffeted by Iranian revolutionary hostage-takers, OPEC’s embargo-inflation, born-again Christian idealism, and implacable Republican, real-politik hostility. (Barbara and I took our eldest, Frank, to Washington and stood on the white House lawn to see Carter greet Prime Minister Morarji Desai.)
And, as an ex-President, Carter made the most of
opportunities to play an elder statesman role on the world stage.
Today was our annual rite of summer passage: pesto day -- an afternoon of cleaning garlic and basil, preparing walnuts, measuring extra-virgin olive oil, Pecorino Romano and Parmagiano Reggiano -- and drinking wine and listening to music and gossiping about friends and noshing on fresh pesto on piccolo como. Result: such a satisfied and mellow mood plus 28 tubs of pesto to freeze, to use up and give away by next August. A highlight of our summer.
Today, in a group of friends on Zoom, one told us about her seatmate
on a recent flight who commented that she was undecided, that she did not know for whom
to vote. My friend said she found herself a bit tongue-tied and posed the
question to the rest of us: what would you have said? A good question: one all of
us should be prepared to answer over the next two months.
What’s your answer?
Some among us talked about safeguarding Democracy; others,
about comparing Trump’s and Harris’ characters and values. For me, I sought to
find common ground between Red and Blue, and then to argue for Blue priorities
and approaches that address today’s household realities. My comments might go
like this:
Trump is right when he says many
Americans feel our nation is not well, that we have been going in the wrong
direction. Take living costs: in April, the price of the standard USDA
statistical basket of groceries was over $86, up more than 25% in the last five
years. Yes, it’s fine that the rate of inflation is dropping, but prices have
gotten painfully high.
Household incomes of the first
three quintiles of the population, i.e., the poor, the lower-middle class, and
the middle-class, have not kept pace. That inflation is down and incomes have
begun to rise still leaves many families squeezed for kitchen-table costs. Car
insurance, auto repairs, costs of eating out -- all are up. Until prices drop and/or pay
increases sharply, many Americans will rightly feel less well-off than before.
COVID is still with us. We don’t
seem to be able to enforce peace on the world anymore. Illegal immigrants keep
coming, even though that too has slowed. And isn’t it wonderful that people all
over the world want to come here? We must be doing something right.
Trump exaggerates when he proclaims coming
depressions, but he’s right that many Americans feel insecure. But – But.
But all of Trumps proposed fixes
only make matters worse! And some of his ideas are total nonsense, such as
rounding up 10 million immigrants and transporting them out of the country. Who’s
going to find and hold them, and how? Who’s going to fly away 10 million passengers,
and to where? What countries are going to take these 10 million folks? And anyway,
if it could be done, who would install his gold-colored escalators and mow his
golf courses?
Seriously, take cost of living
and tariffs. Tariffs will increase the prices of kid’s back to school clothes
and shoes, your pants and shirts, your underwear – making the squeeze on all
but rich families even greater.
Take his tax cut proposals: they favor the upper two quintiles of the population, giving the upper-middle
class and upper class even more advantage over the rest of us. And not taxing
Social Security and tip income? That will drive the deficit up, make the dollar
weaker, increase our national debt, increase interest rates and make it harder
for small business to find the money to invest and grow –- and most of our job
creation comes from small businesses. Not taxing tips only adds to the deficit and leave the Social Security trust fund short. Harris and Trump are both wrong on tip taxation.
No, while Trump’s concerns about
America’s problems may be right, his answers are dead-wrong and help only
billionaires like himself.
Harris and Walz are on the right
track and have the right priorities: improve education, competition, child-care.
Give women freedom to choose to work by providing universal child-care. Extend child tax credits to strengthen families’ ability to raise healthy and confident
children. Underwrite signing bonuses to attract new, top-of-class teachers and promote improved public schools.
Welcome legal immigrants, make it easier to come here properly, and provide a
path to earned citizenship. Rein in banks using your savings to speculate – what used to be called Glass-Steagall – and restrict selling off your home
mortgage and car loans to investors at inflated, phony prices. And raise the National
minimum wage. Use anti-trust and consumer protection powers granted by Congress
to stop huge mergers and rein in big enterprises. Foster competition which
drives prices down. Increase inheritance taxes on the ultra-wealthy to slow
down passing on wealth to offspring who haven’t earned it.
And, overseas, stop
molly-coddling dictators and stand up for democracies, justice, and fairness.
Harris and Walz, in my opinion,
are the trustworthy choice and have the right priorities, values, and programs that address
our problems and opportunities.
Yes, too much; too long-winded, but you get the drift. Your
seatmate may not care about or understand risk to our democracy; he or she may find
Trump’s kick-ass personality and crudeness entertaining, a vicarious venting of their frustration. But everyone cares about their family’s or household’s
daily sense of well-being. That’s what I would focus on.
You may well have a very different answer; indeed, you may favor Red over Blue proposals. But that’s not the point. The point is to have an answer ready and to encourage the undecided to make up their mind and vote. America needs concerned and thoughtful voters this fall as never before.
So,
what are you prepared to say to the undecided you encounter?
Why have I not posted since late May? It’s been an up and down summer – and on this
chill and rainy Seattle day it feels as summer is coming to an end. I hope
September delivers its usual glorious Indian Summer on the Salish Sea –
especially since family will be gathering around the finish line as I end this
90th lap around the sun.
My last post, the Boeing letter below, was from Bayonne, France,
laying at the feet of the board the broken body of Boeing’s reputation for reliability.
Bayonne is not far from Toulouse, Airbus-land; they, too, are not unblemished.
At least the new Boeing CEO, Kelly Ortberg, intends to office much of the time
here in Seattle, where the bulk of Boeing’s employees live and work.
 |
| Cathedral Sainte-Marie de Bayonne |
We ended our tour early and flew for home. But what little we had seen – Carcassonne, Auche, Bayonne, Biarritz, San Sebastian, Bilbao – was wonderful, i.e., truly, filled with wonder.
 |
| Bilbao -- and a cleaned river |
 |
| Carcassonne |
Ann has fully recovered; I still easily get short of breath
and am more tippy than before. It didn’t stop me from enjoying the first three
weeks of July’s Seattle Chamber Music Festival – three concerts each week plus
board events plus hosting in our home cellist Paul Watkins for a week. And then,
last week in July, we decamped for summer school at Cambridge University.
 |
| Selwyn Hall -- and that's half of it |
That was a magical experience: to be bearing a student ID
once again; to attend two, small (<30) lively classes a day, plus plenary lectures each
morning, afternoon and evening; to live in Selwyn College and take breakfast and
dinner in its faux-medieval dining hall with hundreds of other students – young
and old, from 32 countries around the globe – all interested and interesting
people; to be surrounded by a university town offering pubs and restaurants,
drama and concerts, poetry readings and museum events and history around every
corner.
 |
| A Plenary on Cooling the Arctic |
Ann took two two-week courses: World Under Stress taught by Sir Tony Brenton, former UK Ambassador to the Russian Federation, a man who has negotiated with Putin, and, with me, Rome and China – a Comparison of Empires. In addition, I took two one-week courses: Henry IV, Part One and The Hundred Years War. I fell into bed each night exhausted but so mentally stimulated that I had trouble falling asleep.
Plus a side trip to Canterbury and five days in London. God and good health willing, we will go again next year.
 |
| At Selwyn College, Cambridge |
So, thus the long silence from Northwest Ruminations – not that anyone would notice. In England, still tippy, I resorted to a walking stick. Yesterday, I gave a speech to my luncheon club: My Magic Stick, my New BFF.
I
recounted the magical effect my walking stick projects onto people around me – at Heathrow, early
boarding of aircraft; in the London tube, women in their late 50’s getting up
and eagerly offering me their seat; a briefcase wielding business man jay walking
through traffic to get to my side and ask if I was all right as I leaned on a
post-box to catch my breath; the next day, his opposite, a tattooed, studded, skin-head, stepping aside to let me pass with a deferential nod of his shaved head; being
plucked out of line and escorted to the door of the British National Museum – a
magical stick, indeed.
Now summer appears to be winding down, alas. But, you’ll hear from me more frequently.
 |
| From Cheapside |
The following letter was posted last week to the offices of Senator Maria Cantwell and representatives Smith and Larson. Cantwell chairs the Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation. Smith is ranking member of House Armed Services Committee. Larson is ranking member on House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee and serves on its Aviation Sub-committee. These are powerful voices on trade, defense, transportation, aviation and the FAA.
Fletch Waller
Senator Maria Cantwell
Representative Adam Smith
Representative Rick Larson 21
May’24
Dear Senator and Representatives:
Boeing Corp is a national asset that is being diminished
in value by feckless leadership that persists even after its problems and flaws
have become so glaringly evident. I
write as a concerned citizen of Puget Sound; when I discuss Boeing with other non-employees,
like myself, residents here in the greater Seattle area, I often get a rueful
shrug, a "yeah, they have sure screwed up”, but no sense of being a constituent
with a real stake in the company’s performance. Boeing is still, despite its
administrative and manufacturing moves away from Puget Sound, our region’s
largest employer. Its future is in large part ours.
The latest disheartening evidence that the leaders of
Boeing just don’t get it is their $30 million goodbye gift to Calhoun, who was
supposedly overseer of the company’s attempts to right its ship after causing
hundreds of passenger deaths, losing market leadership to Airbus, losing
millions of dollars, and causing its customers untold millions more as portions
of their fleets were grounded. To add injury to insult, the Directors voted
Calhoun onto the Board! What are they thinking!? It confirms my hunch that the
directors don’t know what they don’t know. Moreover, it appears that they do
not care to know.
The Directors are from away, as my Newfoundland grandfather
would say. There is not one Puget Sound-based Director on the Boeing Board. Think
of that: the largest employer in the region without one Director on
its board who lives and works in the region.
It’s not just Puget Sound that has a large stake in
Boeing’s performance and leadership, it’s the US’s also. As our nation’s
largest exporter, all citizens have a stake. At a small dinner with Alan
Mullally years ago, his first sentence in an after-dinner presentation to us was
a stunner: “Britain, Germany, France and Spain are waging war on Puget Sound.”
That was before Boeing leadership decamped to Chicago, before choosing as
President a Jack Welch acolyte rather than a gifted, engineer problem-solver
steeped in the aircraft business (and allowing Ford to benefit from Mullally’s skills and leadership), before shifting HQ again into the Washington DC area.
I don’t know aircraft or defense industries, but I do
know first-hand of leadership and directorship. You three and all your
constituents have a stake in how Boeing pulls out of its nose-dive. What are
your options to intercede? To bring national interests to bear? To help restore
the value of this national asset? Arise.
Sincerely yours, a frustrated and concerned citizen,
Week before last, with four fellow political progressives, I ventured into Eastern Washington to visit and converse with political conservatives about the urban/rural divide. We found on the surface pretty much what one might expect: the divide is real; the distrust deep and damaging, urbans more Democrats and rurals more Republicans. But beneath that superficial simplicity we found fascinating complexities, ambiguities, and sensitivities. It was a rich and rewarding experience.
The trip was
organized by two folks from each side, urban and rural, blues and reds, under
the dual umbrellas of One Small Step and Braver Angels. One Small
Step is a creation of NPR’s StoryCorps. It brings together political opposites
not to argue or convert each other, but to converse, to understand the roots of
political views, of how one’s political beliefs were formed by family, by
upbringing, by lived experience. The goal is to restore civility, to bridge the
divisions that separate us, “to” (from StoryCorp’s mission statement) ”help us
believe in each other” and in our democracy. Its method is to broker formatted
conversations between opposites, one couple at a time. By engaging under agreed
ground rules, we learn to listen to and respect one another. I have had three One
Small Step conversations and look forward to more.
Braver Angels takes a slightly different approach but its
purpose, “to de-polarize America,” is fully in sync with that of One Small Step.
Braver Angels is a national movement that has grown out of 16 people, eight
Donald Trump voters and eight Hilary Clinton voters getting together in a South
Lebanon, Ohio church basement seven years ago to see if they could talk to each
other without the rancor and disrespect they agreed are so dangerously
divisive. They resolved to carry on, spread the idea and took the name “Better
Angels” from Lincoln’s first inaugural address, in March of 1861 by which time
seven Southern States already had voted to secede from the United States. Lincoln’s
inspiring passage:
“We are not enemies, but friends. Though passion
may have strained, it must not break our bonds of affection. The mystic chords
of memory, stretching from every battlefield and patriot grave to every living
heart and hearthstone, all over this broad land, will yet swell the chorus of
the Union, when again touched, as surely they will be, by the better angels of
our nature.”
Yes, his appeal failed; God forbid we fail again. The risk is real.
Despite a copyright challenge that forced a name change to Braver Angels, the organization now has branches in all 50 states. Rather than One Small Step’s person by person, get to know one another approach, Braver Angels takes on issues.
Though still small (only 12,000+ dues paying members) but growing and in alliance with over 100 other orgs, they have held over 3,200 debates, live conferences, panelist conversations before audiences, Zoom conferences, and two annual, national conventions. You want to attend the convention? You must sign up with a politically opposite: voting delegates must be evenly matched, red and blue.
Generally, both Braver Angels and One Small Step find it easier to enroll blues than reds. Are you a Red; are you worried about our increasingly disrespectful and hostile polarization? Then, c’mon – sign up to one or the other or both and help de-polarize America.
https://storycorps.org/discover/onesmallstep/
https://braverangels.org/
-- issues basis
With whom did we meet and what did we do?
Our trip was arranged by Judie Messier, our go-to One Small Stepper. (All five of us are members of Wider Horizons, through which we have come to know one another.) We were hosted by and stayed in the home of two Utah-raised LDSer’s. Rural yahoos, right? Wrong! They are both graduate nuclear physicists, he retired from Rickover’s staff. She is a Republican of the Milton Freidman/Frederick Hyek schools and articulate on both, a district officer of Braver Angels, conflicted over a Trump candidacy and her vote. She says they likely call her a RINO. I would guess she will not vote for Biden. Her husband, a retired Commander, I’m guessing will vote party – while taking time to help his high school grandson with their physics homework. Yes, their; the grandson is transitioning with full acceptance and loving support of his grandparents. Not so simple after all. In their own way, as elite in their rural community as we urban “elites” about whom they complain.
The #1 issue for our hostess: water and we west-side environmentalists who want
to tear out the Snake River dams. She is the activist and a delightful
conversationalist; he chooses to support her and stay in the background. New
friends.
All five of us blues had One Small Step conversations. Mine
was with a health care navigator and consultant, a conservative red, who worked
in Seattle for most of her career but chose to return to her small-town roots where
she helped found the co-housing venture in which she now lives. She is
well-read, incisive, a jazz promoter, and a delightful luncheon companion.
Again, not fitting any shallow stereotype of the red, rural conservative. We
will stay in touch.
That evening there were fourteen of us for dinner put on by
our hostess and host, we five progressives and nine small town or rural
conservatives, all proponents of Braver Angels. At two tables of seven the
conversations about urban and rural became candid, passionate, sometimes
unguarded. After-dinner we all convened in the living room to share what we had
learned and felt.
The next morning, we five watched a national Braver Angels
Zoom conference on rural/urban relations moderated by Sue Lani Madsen, one of
our dinner group the night before. Sue Lani is a very articulate journalist,
activist, Republican leader, volunteer fireman (fireperson?) and skilled EMT. She
also blogs. A recent entry: The party whose nominee is under 70 and does not
have a worm in his brain wins.
After the Zoom session, we went out to the Madsen goat ranch in Edwall, WA. After 14 years as Range Management Specialist with the Natural Resources Conservation Service, Craig Madsen tired of bureaucracy and founded Healing Hooves, a weed control, vegetation removal, and ecosystem management company -- using goats, what else? He and his 250 goats serve individual households and land owners, and also have contracts with towns, school districts, hospitals, and so on throughout the state.
| Rural goats confront urban progressives (without revealing their political leanings.) |
What did we hear?
It’s not just a Washington problem, of course. Like Seattle,
Austin, Atlanta, Minneapolis, Chicago, Columbus, and countless other blue cities
are afloat in seas of red. And the more urbanized the state, the more
frustrated the rural dwellers. The most urbanized states: Cal @ 94.2%, Nev.,
N.J., Fla, Mass @91.3%. The Least urbanized: Vermont @ 35.1%, Maine, W. Va,
Miss, Montana @53.4% (Where our kids and grandkids live: NY, @87.4, Washington
@83.4, Michigan @ 73.5, Minn @ 71.9, Ark @ 55.5%) Perhaps this helps explain
why some Oregonians (80.5%) want to secede and be annexed by Idaho (69.2%.)
It’s nothing new. The derogatory term “city slicker” is from the
19thC; “country bumpkin” dates back to the 17thC! Country folk have long been
suspicious of and alienated from city dwellers; it’s deeply ingrained. My
mother was an upstate NY, tiny-town girl. I recall my Grandmother’s outrage when
my orphaned cousin, whom they raised as their son, brought home an “Eye-talian”
girl.
We heard grumping about “elites.” Yet Sue Lani and Craig
Madsen are elites; our physicists host and hostess are elites; the guy with a
Masters in Agronomy from WSU farming and managing by computer hundreds of acres
of wheat in the Palouse, he is an elite; the John Deere dealer with $4,000,000
of inventory on his small town lot is an elite.
We heard about rural areas not getting their Fair Share,
whatever that means. In fact, most rural counties receive more state support
for roads, schools and so on, than they pay in to the state in real estate and
sales taxes. But that does not make the rurals feel any better.
The myth of the self-reliant homesteader is powerful. That they relied on the Federal government’s subsidies to the railroads, on the government to break treaties and confiscate native Americans’ lands, on government grants of homesteading rights and free land, are conveniently left aside: how the west was "won".
Insights
Phil Gerson, one of we progressive urbanites, offered an
important thought: people who are rooted in place – farmers, small town business
owners, people who prefer their tight, comfortable community – are naturally
cautious, read conservative, about changes to their place, whether it's changing
government regulations, environmentalism, influx of immigrants, whatever. Their
place is their identity. Little wonder, observed Phil, that people rooted in place are more likely than not to be conservative by nature.
By contrast, those of us whose identity has to do with
skills and talents, are more mobile. We likely cluster in cities among a diversity of people and encounter a diversity of ideas. We can more easily than our rural cousins move from one city to another as the market for our skills and talents change. (I, for example, was raised in Washington -- the other Washington, schooled in upstate New York and Boston, raised my family in Minneapolis, and worked in Seattle, Southeast Asia, and Brig, CH. Now retired, it is I who is rooted in place, by choice.)
Sue Lani observed that partisanship can be a healthy route to solutions. What we need, she said, is better partisanship, to which I would add, pragmatic rather than ideological partisanship. Sue Lani and Phil are working together to create a state-wide conference on urban/rural collaboration and cooperation, a worthy effort deserving of our support.
I come away impressed . . .
. . . by the values and character of those we met. These folks value honesty, enterprise, mutual support, and bonds of respect and community. They are likeable. If we can allow our and their better angels to prevail, we will bridge the natural divide between rural and urban, and truly make the American idea work again for all of us. If . . ..
I haven’t blogged in a while, blocked by appalling genocidal wars, campus demonstrations, civil and criminal trials, hometown-company mis-steps, and frightful polls, so a trip to the outdoors was tonic to clear the brain. Our friends Pam and Jim put us onto the Olympic Peninsula, just the tonic I needed.
Right in our backyard: Salmon, Cedar,
Rocks and Rain*
Some of you,
I am sure, are very familiar with the Olympic Peninsula. I did not discover the
richness of the Olympic Peninsula and the Olympic National Park until recently
– long after having put my backpacking and mountain hiking days behind me.
.jpg) |
| Hurricane Ridge, 1986 |
After our
divorce in ’87, I resigned from the Seattle Golf Club (no one resigns from the
Seattle Golf Club!), gave away the sticks and began to explore. But it was
eastward I looked, toward ski areas, Alpine lakes, Mt. Rainier, and the
Cascades. I climbed Rainier in ’88 (@14,411, highest in the lower 48.)
After meeting Ann and marrying in ’91
it was skiing in the Methow and Sun Valley, mountain hiking on Rainier and in the Cascades,
exploring Mt. Saint Helens; we climbed Adams together; sailed in the San Juans
and Gulf Islands. I fly fished the Deschutes and in BC – but all this time, ignored
the Olympics.
A month or so ago, with friends Jim and Pam, we planned an Olympics trip. I began to
bone up on what this Olympic Peninsula has to offer. And OMG, what I have missed all these years!
The Olympic National Park which centers the peninsula is, in the lower 48, the largest wilderness uncrossed by roads; you can drive 20 or so miles into it from various spots on its perimeter, but to go through it – only backpackers can navigate through the Dan Evans Wilderness which is the center of the park, a three-night, four day trek. Jumbled mountains, meandering rivers, fluky weather. Tuesday, Ann and I drove 18 miles from sea level in sunny Port Angeles to 5,200’ – one mile up in 18 miles --
.jpg) |
| Hurricane Ridge 2024 |
We visited
the Ho Rain Forest – nice but unnecessary for there are rain forests nearly
everywhere on the peninsula’s Southwest side. But the Ho is the departure point for hiking to and climbing Mt. Olympus. Rain forests are spooky and
silent -- not so silent if you stand still and listen hard, Moss-draped, gigantic, thousand-year-old spruces, pines, firs, cedars
– myriad ferns and mosses: botany on adrenaline.
Can you picture the peninsula? It’s arrowhead-shaped, with its point, Cape Flattery, to the northwest, as far from Key West as you can get short of Alaska or Hawaii. It’s bounded on the north by the Straits of Juan de Fuca; on the east by Hood Canal; on the south by Grays Harbor, Hoquiam, Aberdeen and connections to Olympia; and on the west by the raging Pacific, which is anything but pacific along that 140-mile rocky, hay-stacked shore. (And it houses some delightfully, outrageously named towns: try Humptulips for one, or Dosewallops.)
It was on that hay-stacked shore that we joined Jim and Pam at La Push, HQ of the Quileute Reservation. The town speaks of tribes without casinos or oil: trailers, RV's or ramshackle clapboard houses, yards full of junked cars and rusting appliances. The town lives on commercial fishing, logging, and tourism.
The Quileute Oceanside Resort is owned and operated by the tribe, so I mistakenly expected little. In fact, we shared a beautifully appointed two-bedroom house right on the drift-wood studded, surf-pounded beach with haystacks just off-shore. The house is quality construction and tastefully, fully appointed.
.jpg) |
| The view from our living room @ Quileute Oceanside Resort |
And those beaches -- #’s 1,2,3, and Rialto (I think the Quileutes need some branding help, don’t you?) -- those beaches go on forever. Did it rain? Of course: cold, wet, and windy – that comes with the territory.
-2.jpg) |
| Quileute #2 |
But, if
fresh water and lake lodges are your thing, stay as we did one night in
Quinault Lodge on Lake Quinault, in the Quinault Indian Nation (no visa needed.)
The room was a bit weird, but the restaurant is excellent and the staff
couldn’t have been more pleasant and proficient. The menu creative and wine list ample.
Lake Crescent
is the lake not to miss. Stunningly beautiful, as pretty as any we hiked around
in Switzerland during my tours of teaching hospitality management at University
Center, Cesar Ritz. Lake Crescent Lodge we’ll try next time.
The Quileute
and Quinault are two of six indigenous language families on the peninsula –
Makah, Klallam, Chemakum, Twana, Chehalis, Quinault, and Quileute. There are nine
major tribes within those language groups, all with their distinctive traditions, their prides and woes, but all share a
will to survive and thrive. In each of the nine major tribes there are sub-clans
that claim their own distinct identities.
Some thrive
more than others – the Quileute are dependent on fishing, lumbering and
tourism; others have their casinos, some industry, but always tourism – theirs
is the Olympic peninsula. Save for a few Anglo settlements such as around Gray’s
Harbor and up at Port Angeles, Sequim, Port Townsend, the tribes and indigenous
folk are the People of the Peninsula. This is their land; they have fought
for it, care about it and fight for the right to be care-givers to it and its
wildlife.
And if
wildlife is your thing, have deer, Roosevelt elk, sea otters, river otters, black
bear, (grizzlies may be coming,) grey whales, humpbacks, orcas, marmots, mountain
goats (being removed and wolves being re-introduced), seals, lynx, cougar,
bobcat, five species of oysters, eleven of clams, plus mussels, urchins, and over 300 species of birds. While Ann and I
ate lunch along the shore at Port Angeles, we watched a river otter gathering her
lunch off the rocks right below us.
And, of
course, the salmon – five species of that miraculous, spiritual symbol of life sacrificed
for generations to come. Frank N and I camped out by the Elwha twelve years
ago, when the first dam was removed. Now the salmon have returned; harvestable,
sustainable runs are nearly back.
Salmon,
Cedar, Rock and Rain*. Go and explore this treasure of ours. All four sides of
it – and if you’re still young enough, backpack that interior. The best
wilderness area of the Lower 48 awaits you – right in my backyard.
%20(1%20of%201)-4.jpg) |
| Fort Worden (or is that a Hopper?) |
