Monday, October 7, 2013

The Emasculation of the Presidency

I was born a year and a half into FDR's first term.  The magic 100 days had passed; the Supreme Court had not yet dismantled a number of his initiatives.  Though the country was still in the grip of depression, his actions and the confidence Roosevelt beamed from the White House had lifted Americans' spirit and revived, albeit tentatively, hope that we could find our way forward.

In adolescence, I was an avid fan of Mr. President, a serial radio drama in which Edward Arnold portrayed historical episodes from past Presidencies, revealing only in the last minute the name of the President being portrayed.  I read boy's biographies of Presidents.  I absorbed from my parents an automatic respect for and admiration of our President.

Meanwhile, for the next half century, the American Presidency steadily coalesced power; The Great Depression, WWII, the Atomic Age and Cold War, proliferation of regulatory agencies (authorized by Congress, mind),The Cuban Missile Crisis and Viet Nam, the secrecy of CIA and NSA all swung the pendulum of power toward the Executive and away from Congress.  Mainly, it was the Judiciary that kept the pendulum from over-swinging. 

So perhaps it's no surprise that I admire a President who can lead and speak for all of us, whom Congress respects, who generates awe and affection from our friends and awe and fear from our foes. 

But... for good or ill, the American Presidency is an institution in decline.

Hamilton wrote in Federalist #70 that "Energy in the Executive is a leading character in the definition of good government."  And "A feeble executive is but another phrase for a bad execution; and a government ill executed, whatever it may be in theory, must be, in practice, a bad government."

Surely, Hamilton and Madison would have been alarmed at the imbalance of power in the '40s, '50's and '60's.  But how would they react today, as the Presidency becomes increasingly toothless, on the verge of emasculation. 

In his landmark work, The American Presidency, Clinton Rossiter's first lecture enumerated the powers of the Presidency.  He listed five chartered by the Constitution; let's take a look.
·         Chief of State, i.e., the ceremonial head of government, who with real of feigned enthusiasm greets dignitaries, bestows medals, pardons turkeys, proclaims holidays, throws out first pitches, and all the rest.  What may seem frivolous is necessary to stay in touch with our people and generate empathy from them for what Rossiter called "a one-man distillation of the American People."  
Reagan played this role to the hilt.  But Clinton's peccadilloes and W's Texas swagger and entangled syntax weakened the role.  Has Obama, simply by illustrating the growing diversity of Americans, inherently fragmented any single father-figure image Chief of State?
·         Chief Executive, i.e., the supervisor of the government, through the powers to appoint and remove, in order -- as the Constitution demands -- to "take care that the laws be faithfully executed."  With the explosion of independent regulatory agencies, increasingly complex bills coming out of Congress, signing statements from the White House, and an distressingly activist, reactionary court, can anyone be singly and confidently held accountable for what Hamilton called good administration: Federalist #68, "The true test of a good government is its aptitude and tendency to produce a good administration."   Remember "your doin' a heckuva job, Brownie"? 
·          Commander in Chief of the military might as well as of the vast and increasingly intrusive intelligence apparatus.  Has Obama weakened this role by his waffling over the "red line" in Syria?  Does anyone take him seriously that military options are still on the table?  Maybe in this case, it is for the best, but no one doubted Lincoln, as Commander in Chief, "clothed in immense power."  Is the Commander still Chief when his Intelligence czar and head of NSA get caught lying to Congress and us about what they are snooping into, and the President has not yet called them to account or fired anyone; is this role, too, being eaten away from within?
·         Chief Diplomat; the two elements of this are formulation of foreign policy and  the conduct of foreign affairs.  In Federalist #75, Hamilton explains the role of the executive as sole representative to foreign governments and of the Senate as constraint and contact with the will of the people.  Two Supreme Court decisions, in 1799 and 1936, confirm those roles.  Yet in recent years, more and more treaties lie languishing for lack of Senate action to either ratify or reject.  No fewer than nine human rights treaties await action, dating back to 1977, and countless other important items like Law of the Seas, environmental treaties, and trade treaties are blocked from consideration, usually by a minority of the Senate.  Moreover, junketing Representatives and Senators, e.g., Lindsey Graham and John McCain visiting with rebels in Syria, muck about in what should be Executive Branch domain. 
Another element of diplomacy is foreign respect.  Consider what has happened as America has screwed up Iraq, been befuddled in Afghanistan, looked rudderless in Syria, become the fall guy for all sides that the Arab Spring has sprouted, and been flaunted and lectured to by Vladmir Vladmirovitch.  
  • ·         Chief Legislator.  Congress deals with such a complex myriad of issues, and represents so many conflicting interests, that the Constitutional charge that the President "shall from time to time give to Congress information on the state of the union, and recommend to their consideration such measures as he shall judge expedient" (Article II, Section 3) has become a major function.  It is mentioned in passing in Federalist #77, but in such a way as to indicate it was then almost an afterthought to the authors.  It grew to be a critical role; Roosevelt, Johnson, even Eisenhower, put their stamp on legislation.  But today, Presidential budgets and legislative proposals are virtually DOA with Congress openly disdainful of the office. 
Rossiter  goes on to add five more roles of a President that over time and through the evolution of our democratic republic have become part of his or her job. 
  • ·         Chief of The Party.  But look at Obama's inability to corral his own.   Democrats defy his appointments, lobby against candidates (e.g., Larry Summers) and set their own agenda.  Some think this fine, but Obama's unwillingness to play party boss and chief stroker has undermined his authority within his own ranks.
  • ·         Voice of The People.  Lincoln and the Roosevelts established this role, but ever since, with easy access to media, many "voices of the people" have diminished the awe and respect for the voice of the President.  The networks sometimes decline to broadcast his oval office addresses.
  • ·         Protector of the Peace: this stems from the power to declare emergencies and issue decrees.  The Emergency Banking Act, 1933, and Securities and Exchange Act, 1934, even give the President power to suspend financial activity.  But the concentration of financial power, lobbying pressure and campaign contributions have nullified such authority.  Yes, the President still can declare emergency in case of natural disasters, but not likely man-made ones.
  • ·         Manager of Prosperity.  The Full Employment Act, the Council of Economic Advisors, the annual Economic Report and all the rest appear to create this role for him or her -- but it is, of course, an impossible expectation to be lived up to.  No President has the power today to "manage" our economy, and the more they try, the more impotent they appear.
  • ·         Leader of the Free World.  Like it or not, sought or not, this role was thrust upon our President in 1945 and doubly so in 1989.  But today?  A mockery... a third of the world resists us, another third dislikes us and the rest is in doubt about our leadership after the Iran-Contra scandal, the humbling on 9/11, the Bush/Cheney folly of Iraq, the quagmire of Afghanistan, and the impressive rise of a China who appears able to get things done.

One might say that it is an impossible job.  But nonetheless, in all ten roles, the American Presidency is increasingly tarnished, increasingly emasculated.  To many, this is not unwelcome.  To my libertarian friends, all government is too powerful, Executive and Congress.  And they like the tilt of the Supreme Court (though they should beware its taste for corporate libertarians.)  But to others, it is a regrettable trend.  I, for one, am distressed.

Can this be reversed?  Yes, certainly the public's congenital willingness to embrace magnetic personalities means another avuncular Reagan might appear to reverse the decline, as he did our Nixon/Ford/Carter malaise.  A new national crisis might give rise to another Lincoln or FDR.  But in the meantime, the American Presidency is being emasculated by our political incapacity (gerrymandered safe seats and money politics), by self-inflicted wounds (like Bush/Cheney's vendetta against Saddam Hussein), by lack of understanding what a President must be and do (Obama?), and by world affairs beyond our ken (the Arab Spring, Islamic fundamentalism, the rise of China.) Are we satisfied with this -- to have a string of Buchanans or Hardings?

No.  The American Presidency is a unique institution, the finest creation of the Constitutional Convention.  We need to reverse the emasculation and restore the presidency in power and prestige for I believe an effective and energetic  President is necessary to the continuing productivity, confidence and unity of America. 

  

Wednesday, September 4, 2013

Decapitate Rejection

With but one exception, my post "Decapitate" has been met with opprobrium. (I love it when I can use a new word -- even better when in conversation.)  Anyway, yes -- strong rejection and disagreement.  Not just illegal and amoral, but also reducing ourselves to the lowest denominator tactics of our enemies; triggering a round of retribution attacks; encouraging distribution of WMD to terrorist organizations, undermining legitimacy of international justice organizations; earning distrust of allies and enemies, alike ... and so on.

In the cool light of day, my critics are probably right.  But they do not have counters to my arguments that any other response -- limited pinprick or change of regime campaign -- is worse.  Frankly, I hope Congress denies the President's request to embark on a self-defeating course.  I would rather stand down and plead impotency when it comes to sorting out or bringing sense to the chaos that is the Middle East today.

How satisfying it would be to decapitate the bastard ... but cooler heads should prevail.

Monday, September 2, 2013

Decapitate

Obama wants to make a punitive strike on Syria.  Stupid.  Syria didn't order its citizens gassed, Assad did. Obama wants it to be surgical and limited -- not to punish, after all, but in hope of sustaining what little credibility we still have with allies.  We have to strike because we said we would.  Perhaps Obama deserves a punishment for having made dumb red-line boasts. He used the phrase "shot across the bow."  A shot across the bow goes harmlessly into the sea.  No, misspoke: he means, some real hurt -- but of limited duration and extent. Like being half-pregnant? And any collateral damage will only strengthen Assad's moralistic outrage.  All a limited strike will do is underscore how limited are our options and how wary we are of taking risk. A pin-prick would not slow this or other Assad wanna-bes.

McCain wants a major military thrust to change the regime.  Equally stupid.  We ally ourselves with whom? Al-Qaeda?  We enter into a dirty civil war with extremists on every side, become enmeshed in another toxic swamp of Middle-East rivalries we don't begin to understand, spill blood and spend borrowed money in fruitless quest of regional stability.

The only strike that fits the crime (and Obama's need to be taken seriously) is decapitation.  When a tyrant gasses his own population, he should lose his head. Obama must have plenty of spooks -- ours or Israel's or Jordan's or somebody's who have a plan to accomplish it.  Unleash them.  If no plan is feasible with a high probability of success, fold our tent and withdraw from the Middle East.  We don't belong there, anyway.

Decapitation.  Illegal? Yes.  Immoral?  Less so than punitive strike or attempted regime change that would wound and kill innocent by-standers.  Playing God again?  We've already transgressed there.  Decapitate and don't look back. 

Saturday, August 10, 2013

Wagner Blew It

Last Saturday, Ann and I entered the world of Wagner -- The Ring Cycle. A back-of-house tour; four operas (Sunday, Monday, Wednesday and Friday) sixteen hours in all, plus a three hour lecture ahead of each; a five hour seminar covering parodies of Wagner (including Bugs Bunny, of course), Wagner's antisemitism, leit-motifs and musical invention, comparison of Wagner and Verdi; a Q&A luncheon with the director; an evening with Speight Jenkins recalling his thirty years of presenting The Ring; plus entering a contest to create, in treatment form, a "fifth opera" of the cycle. (My entry, Erda's Lament, one of eight from the couple of hundred attendees, did not win.)

We were immersed in a sea of RingChasers. Seattle's quadrennial Ring Cycle is world renowned. Some folks have seen 25 and more Rings on every continent (save Antarctica; a penguin cast Ring, now that would be a kick!)  This was Ann's and my second Ring -- mere pikers.  These professional and dilettante Wagnerites are expert on every arcane nugget --when he wrote what; which philosophers were at the moment affecting him over the course of the 28 years it took him to complete the work, why he chose to use oboes here and clarinets there and to invent his own Wagner Tuba along the way, how his critics carped and complained, and on and on and on.  So my thoughts herein should be regarded as the musings of the rankish of amateurs -- and I am sure they are not unique.  Nonetheless...

... I can't help thinking Wagner blew it.  His set out not only to create a revolutionary new form of musical drama, but also to give the Germanic peoples (they were not yet a country) their unifying myth, as the Norse had in the Edda, the Greeks in Oresteia, the Romans in the Aeneid. (Do we have a unifying myth?  But that is for another ruminations.) He sought to give Germans a hero, one whose values reflect love, freedom, naturalness, and purity, one who does not depend upon intercession of Gods for success and fulfillment. Siegfried was this new hero.  But as Wagner's ideals mutated and changed, as his personal screw-ups and values warped, he let his hero become less and less so.

Siegfried is no hero.  Fearless, yes, as is any teenager; self-centered, arrogant, daring, insensitive to others, dismissive of authority, a braggart.  He slew a dragon not for gain but because it was there.  He had been told no one else could do so.  He braved the fires and awakened Brunhilde not out of love but because it was said only the bravest could do so.  He impulsively was smitten by this first woman he had ever seen, this Valkyrie daughter of Earth and the Supreme God, but despite her renouncing her godliness and teaching him all she knew about the Gods, the world, courage and cowardice, off he stupidly went, this self-proclaimed dragon-slayer, to be flattered, conned, awed by power and pomp, to renounce love and be used as a pawn. No model hero he.

Yet Wagner had his hero in hand all along. Brunhilde is our hero. She is all the prejudiced, embittered, revolutionary nationalist might have wanted. Perhaps he chose not to proclaim her as such, leaving it for us to discover on our own.  Perhaps he was bound by that 19thC presumption of male superiority and precedent. But I think he just got tired and wouldn't think outside his box any longer.  Brunhilde embodies the nadirs of both love and power, one independent and self-determined but aware of her relationship with her world, one compassionate but in touch with her own rights and emotions.

Brunhilde is the hero Wagner sought -- and gave us in spite of himself.            

Friday, August 2, 2013

My Death Is Certain

I have been studying a work by Stephen Batchelor, a notable Buddhist scholar and writer.  He poses this conundrum, which has captured my attention for the past month or so:
                "Since death alone is certain, and the time of death uncertain, what should I do?" 
This profoundly simple question beguiles me.  First, since having left the presidency of a couple of not-for-profits, I have more free time to enjoy and invest; and secondly, I am approaching the end of my eighth decade.  So, since death is certain but the time of mine uncertain, what shall I do?

My answers aren't the point, for one's answers are particular and individual, but I will share how I went about developing my answers.

First, I reviewed my mission statement. Yes, just as in corporate life, consultancy, and not-for-profits, where I helped enterprises clarify their missions, when I retired, I wrote a mission statement for Fletch Waller, thanks to Scott Okie's example. Basically, it's still relevant, but I did modify it in one respect.  Second, I renewed my resolve to stay in shape.  

Third, I thought through what principles or specs could guide me to "what I shall do."  There turned out to be eight of them:
1.  Be of Service to someone, something.   I have been very lucky; the world has treated me well.  I need to pay back in whatever small way I can.
2.  Associate With Good People who can lift me up, teach me, inspire me, provide models.  I don't have time to suck up to "the right people" whose ethics or values or behavior might be questionable.
 3. Work at What I Love; work is the operative word: expend effort.  And don't fart around, Fletch, with should dos or ought tos.
4.  Seek to Lead sounds arrogant, but given experiences and mistakes -- from a few of which I hope I've learned -- try to influence whatever person or group I become involved in.  Lead informally.
5.  Be Forward Looking instead of loitering in the caboose reflecting down the tracks on where you've been.  Stay in the present, mindful, alert, asking "what might this portend; what is coming next?"
6.  Empathize.  Try to imagine what the world looks like through the other's eyes.  Empathy is the essential bridge builder, the connective tissue of civilization.
7.  Make Amends to all ignored, harmed, hurt by me.  Don't check out with bills unpaid.
8.  Act; with apologies to Nike, "Just Do It" diligently, relentlessly.  No time for grand plans, no procrastination.


Try the question on for size.  Since death alone is certain and the time of death uncertain, what should you do? 

Thursday, July 11, 2013

PS re FISC

The NYT reported that the secret court received 1800 requests for warrants last year -- and issued 1800 warrants, some very sweeping dragnets not focused on a particular event or suspect.  Let's see: a year might be 50 weeks, a work-week five days, so 250 days; 1800 warrants, that's 7.2 per day, or nearly one per hour.  Quite a pace for careful jurisprudence by this secret court of eleven secret jurists. Feel safer?

McClatchy has brought a second item to light.  After young Spc. Manning dumped docs to WikiLeaks, Obama, in October of 2011, signed an Executive Order making it an offense for government employees not to inform on co-workers who display suspicious attitudes or behavior, employees who later come under investigation.  Called "Early Warning" or some such innocuous, positive name -- remind one of Stasi by chance?  No, perish the thought; our elected officials are so much more trustworthy than that, and it's for our own good, all in pursuit of security, right, right, right-oh, on we go!

Tuesday, July 2, 2013

Snowden Isn't the Story....

This Snowden kid has had me tongue-tied; I haven't blogged for a month because people keep asking me what I think, where I come out -- traitor or hero?  It's taken me time to take my eye off Snowden and look at the real story.

A novelist coming up with this plot would be laughed out of his editor's office.  Yet here is Snowden, on ice in Moscow, passport-less, cooling his heels in the Sheremetyevo Novotel's in-transit wing -- as deep in a freezer as the journalists' cell phones he demanded be checked into his hotel room refrigerator back in Hong Kong.  Bizarre....  No, he hasn't entered the Russian border their foreign secretary sanctimoniously assures us.  But you can bet his computers and thumb drives have crossed many a border -- seized. copied and cracked by China's MSB and Russia's SVR, FSB and FSO.

OK, so traitor or hero?
                                                                                                                        
Clearly, he is a traitor to his oaths, to his employers and their trust.  And among his employers to whom he swore oaths were the NSA and the CIA.  In releasing information about snooping on foreign governments -- friend and foe -- he has betrayed US government secrets.  His grand motive, he alleges, is to alert the US public to illegal snooping on us -- but that is quite different from his information on international snooping, which is merely unethical, immoral, embarrassing, unwise, self-damaging and stupid -- but not, unfortunately, illegal.  Now we learn that his real job was not system administrator but infrastructure analyst -- searching for ways to penetrate secure systems for intelligence gathering and, potentially, sabotage.  This, too, he has revealed.  So, yes, he is prima facie a traitor.  And his treachery has hurt the US -- with adversaries, allies and those on the sidelines simply keen on indulging their schadenfreude at our expense.

Hero?  Hardly.  Nothing heroic about this self-absorbed computer geek anointing himself as defender of truth.  His allegations about his plans, his job history, his course work at Johns Hopkins, his adoption of Buddhism in Japan while not liking their culture, running off to Hong Kong because of their dedication to liberty??? What kind of naif is this? Facebooking about his sexual prowess; unable to finish high school or community college; claiming he broke his leg in special forces training in the Army Reserve (there isn't such a thing -- there are two National Guard special forces units, otherwise the only five others are regular Army.)   No, no hero is this Snowden.

What of redemption?  
Well, perhaps he has performed a public service if -- a big if -- the public ire is finally aroused to demand a wholesale change, a dismantling of the intelligence-contractor-congressional complex.  Whatever happens to Snowden will be punishment -- whether put on trial here, eking out a living in Ecuador, accepting asylum in Russia, being a pawn in the game of let's embarrass the United States.  Whatever happens to Snowden is not the story.

The story is how our government has prostituted its values in the name of security.   Abraham Lincoln said "America will never be destroyed from the outside. If we falter and lose our freedoms, it will be because we destroyed ourselves."  The intelligence-contractor-congressional system of circular authorizations bolstered by sweeping warrants granted by a secret judiciary is no different than the star chamber justice of Tudor England.  That was finally overturned in the Glorious Revolution of 1688 and we reiterated our rejection  of such process in 1789.

I could rant several more pages about the intelligence swamp we are hip deep in: about the contractors who hire geeks like Snowden despite a crazy personal and professional history, and pay him twice what a comparable civil service post can pay; about 850,000 people or more with top secret clearance, of whom 1 in 3 work for for-profit contractors rather than for the taxpayer; about Defense Secretary Gates testifying that  "I can't get a number on how many contractors work for the Office of the Secretary of Defense;" about the training of CIA spies being contracted out to a for-profit company.  But I won't indulge ....
Suffice to say that information empowers.  And many believe that withholding information empowers absolutely, despite that information is fungible and eventually -- always -- leaks.  Yes power corrupts, but more to the point, John Adams warned that “Power always thinks it has a great soul and vast views beyond the comprehension of the weak."  We have seen it over and over -- the beguiling quality of "secrets" whether wielded by J. Edgar Hoover tempting the Kennedys, or IRS files tempting Johnson, or CIA tempting Nixon, and on and on.  The Frank Church hearings in 1976 restored some constraint on the Executive Branch, but it leaked away again in Iran Contra under Reagan, and again after 9/11 under Bush, Cheney and Obama.  I'm shocked to list Obama in that set but the hubris is the same.  In 2004, we learned of domestic spying; in 2010, The Washington Post explored the runaway intelligence establishment.  Haven't we come to see that these intelligence czars are just as self-anointed as Snowden, thinking alike that they know what's best for us?  When will we learn to distrust any and all of them?  They don't have souls any greater than yours and mine.

The American public accepts this pernicious intrusion because they've been sold a "War on Terror."  There's the root of the problem:  the paradigm of war, that sense of imminent danger which allows those empowered by information to trade us "security" in return for giving up our rights.  But they didn't forestall the Boston Marathon bombers or the guy who tried to blow up Times Square or the guy wearing explosive jockey shorts.  There is no such thing as "security."  And now, the administrations' (plural) lies and wholesale snooping are naked before us.  James Madison wrote "no nation can preserve its freedom in the midst of continual warfare" but that's what we've been sold -- and we have been losing our freedom.  Talk to those denied airline flights with neither explanation nor recourse.  Madison was talking about the danger of concentrating power in the executive long before NSA, CIA, DIA and a hundred other snoop bureaucracies were even dreamed of.
  

Snowden isn't the story.  The story is we are overdue for a sweeping change in what rights we cede to our government and how it accounts for its protection of our rights and its constraint of them.  Now is the time to begin writing that story....